Translate

Friday, February 03, 2023

The Reformation and the Counter-Reformation

The Reformation and Counter-Reformation

A response to a growing decadence

The Reformation started at the beginning of the fifteenth century. It lasted until the end of the seventeenth century with the implementation of the decrees of the Council of Trent (1545-1563). This reform movement came about because of these negative realities: the increasing decadence of the popes, the general laxity of the clergy, the excessive financial demands of the Holy See, and the political encroachments of the papacy. These negative realities caused some voices to be raised against Rome: protesting voices like John Huss, Erasmus, Martin Luther, Servetus, Zwingli, and Calvin, to name some. Many of these protesting voices broke up with the Catholic Church. These events soon affected religious life in Europe so greatly that the Holy Roman Empire eventually fell to pieces.

The Counter-Reformation, Trent, and the Spanish leadership

Because of the very divisive events that followed one after another, the Church had to establish her doctrine more solidly to confute the protesting voices which sought to undermine also what was good in Catholicism. It took the Catholic Church to organize a Council (Trent) that lasted for twenty-five sessions within a span of eighteen years before a satisfactory definition of the Catholic faith was re-established. This movement to redefine the Catholic foundation was the Counter-Reformation. Though the Holy Roman Empire fell into pieces as a result of many divisive events, the Holy See at Rome had delegated to the king of Spain a spiritual sovereignty not only within the framework of Spain's continental territory but also extended to the New World (the Americas). This is the reason why the proponents of the Counter-Reformation came from the Spaniards St. Teresa of Avila, St. John of the Cross and St. Ignatius of Loyola.

The Catholic Reformation at the grass roots

Though the Counter-Reformation had its main movement in ecclesiastical and hierarchical circles, there was also the same movement in the grass roots level. On a small scale, there were devout leaders who moved their religious order to undertake reform. Already mentioned were St. Teresa of Avila and St. John of the Cross - both reformers of their Carmelite Order. Aside from these two, there were also: the Franciscan Observatine preachers St. Bernardine of Siena and St. John Capistrano; the Benedictines of Bursfeld and Melk Congregations; the Dominican Lombard Congregation; and many Augustinian monasteries. The reform movement in these religious communities had achieved a certain degree of renewal and was sustained to a certain degree. However, renewal in these grass roots level was not as completely obtained as that of the leaders of the Council, since there often was no support coming from ecclesiastical circles.

Spiritual inspiration and centers of influence

In other grass roots sectors of the Church, there were also some great works and outstanding contributions to the Counter-Reformation movement. One of these was the work of Geert Groote (d. 1384) - who lived a spirituality that captures the ideals embedded in the classic spiritual work, "The Imitation of Christ". Two important fifteenth century congregations - the Canons of St. Augustine of Windesheim and the Brethren of the Common Life - owed their beginnings to Groote's inspiration. Another center of renewal and spiritual influence during this time came from the Carthusian Order. This religious order, founded by St. Bruno, is spiritually structured so as to have no need for reform. Their charterhouse at Cologne exerted quite a considerable influence to many devotees and acted as a spiritual center for many peoples.

Division in Christianity

Since at the grass roots level, which also includes the parishes and the lay faithful, the works of the reformers was constantly frustrated by the failure of the Church hierarchy to support them, many turned to the other doctrines and teachings of the Protestant reformers. As a result, Christian Europe was divided. The whole of northern Germany became Lutheran while the whole of Western Germany became Calvinist. England and her Anglican Church soon broke up with Rome. Only in the south of Europe did the influence of Rome remain unshaken: in Italy, Spain, Austria and Bohemia. In France, most of the French remained Catholic but their sovereigns veered toward Protestantism. This religious schism that gripped Europe also became part of an international war that not only involved mutual excommunications but also the spread of violence and strife. This fight raged on not only between brothers, among families, and between cities, but also among groups of peoples and nations.

Restoration in the post-Tridentine Church

After the Council of Trent applied the implementation of the decrees, the restoration of Catholic life began. This restoration was to be one of the most wonderful phenomena in Church history. Some historians refer to it as an "era of saints". The Catholic faithful, which felt like a retreating army against the Protestant reformers, now gave way to a new battle spirit and a rediscovered self-assurance. And those who also were not overcome during the height of the Protestant reformers influence, but remained very loyal to the practices of their beliefs, now once again rejoiced in their faith. What now appeared in the frontline of ecclesiastical reforms are those who were gifted with the charisma of saints - with saints like St. Pius V (the first pope who became a saint after a lapse of three hundred years), St. Charles Borromeo (the archbishop of Milan who reformed the diocesan seminary structure of the Church), and St. Francis de Sales (the bishop of Geneva who co-founded the Visitation Order and wrote the great spiritual classic, "Introduction to the Devout Life").

Summary

The Reformation and Counter-Reformation movements teach us that the Church, although of divine nature, has human elements. It is the human entity in the Church that is always in need of reform - at any time. Along her history, the Church was led into practices that caused her moral degeneration and a degree of laxity in her system. It was during the 15th-17th centuries wherein the Church was seen to be more in need of reform than any of the centuries that have passed. What is sad was that the reform movement was divided completely. Martin Luther did not intend to break up with the Catholic Church at the start of his protest. However, events led to the division of the Reformation into a Protestant Reformation and a Catholic Reformation. The Catholic Reformation or Counter-Reformation, however was able to restore the dignity of the Church that was almost destroyed by the events that transpired during this very critical centuries. It was the Council of Trent that provided the solution to the crisis.

Tuesday, January 31, 2023

French School of Spirituality

French School of Spirituality: A Catholic Reform Spirituality Implementing Reform Initiatives of the Council of Trent

Catholic Reform Spirituality - Tridentine Spirituality

French school of spirituality

A major infuence in Catholic spirituality were the Spanish medieval writers and spiritual masters like Teresa of Avila, John of the Cross, and Ignatius of Loyola. But in the seventeenth century onward, it was the French school of spirituality that also became influential. The foundation and seedbed for this school of spirituality was not the monasteries or universities, but discussion groups. In these groups we find the Carmelite Mary of the Incarnation, Benedict of Canfield, and Pierre de Bérulle. They met in simple living rooms. Canfield's Exercise of the Will of God stressed holiness as accessible to all. Its central theme is the experience of God where the person participates in the self-emptying of Jesus in His passion. Bérulle likewise teaches this same participation in the mysteries of Christ. In his Grandeurs de Jesus, he writes that the goal of Christian life is to reproduce on earth the adoration and servitude of Christ in heaven.

Francis de Sales

The seventeenth century was also the era of Francis de Sales. His classic work, "Introduction to the Devout Life", is an important treatment of the lay faithful's pursuit of holiness in everyday life. His friend, Jane Frances de Chantal, foundress of the Visitation Order, was instrumental in making Francis de Sales' theory and practice of spiritual direction one with lasting influence.

The Council of Trent

The Church Council that influenced the French school of spirituality (and all schools of spirituality at the time) was the Council of Trent. The reforms implemented in the Council of Trent (1545-1563 A.D.) followed a decree on justification that stressed the importance of good works. Therefore, Tridentine Catholics would now conceive spiritual perfection as involving a high degree of personal activity - combining an active striving for self-control, the acquisition of virtue, and a zeal for works of mercy and charity. All these activities spring from a form of meditative prayer (which began in the fifteenth century). Foremost among the spiritual masters who followed this Tridentine spirituality or Catholic reform spirituality, in the context of the French school were Francis de Sales(1567-1622 A.D.), Vincent de Paul (1581-1660 A.D.), and Pierre de Bérulle (d. 1629 A.D.). These men were instrumental in developing the science of meditation that reformed both the clergy and the lay faithful.

Eucharistic piety

To balance the high degree of personal activity in the reformed spirituality of Trent, there was also an equal insistence on the truth that God is the One who really does it all. God's grace and the channels of this grace became important. Emphasis was thus placed on the sacraments. A Eucharistic piety developed and became the distinguishing feature of modern Catholicism: many priests and bishops now began the daily celebration of the Mass. This Eucharistic piety also extended to other nonliturgical practices like the adoration of the Blessed Sacrament in benediction services. It is this Tridentine spirituality that began to place all prayer and activity in the context of the Eucharist.

Leading exponents of the French school

The new spirituality of Trent found its finest expression in a considerable number of men whose impact was strong enough to create distinct schools. In the French school of spirituality, an outstanding exponent of this spirituality is French author, cardinal, and leading statesman, Pierre Cardinal de Bérulle. P. de Bérulle founded the French Oratory for the sanctification of priests in 1611 A.D. Others who followed suit were Jean-Jacques Olier, who founded the Sulpicians for the formation of priests in 1657 A.D.; Jean Eudes, who founded the Eudists for the formation of priests for the popular missions in 1643 A.D.; Vincent de Paul, who founded the Lazarists for the mission in the countrysidein 1651 A.D.; Jean-Baptiste de La Salle, who founded the Christian Brothers for the education of the youth in 1680 A.D.; Claude Poullart des Places, who founded the Missionaries of the Holy Spirit for the missions abroad, in 1703 A.D.; and Louis-Marie Grignion de Montfort, who founded the Missionaries of the Company of Mary.

Pastoral reforms of Trent

Pastoral reforms initiated by the Council of Trent and applied by the French school.

  • preaching and giving the Word of God its rightful place
  • bishops being domiciled in their own dioceses
  • control on the clergy
  • examination of knowledge in the faith
  • the need to have something to live on
  • a cassock or formal priestly attire
  • a reformed liturgy
  • seminaries for the formation of clerics

Historical role of the French school in Catholic America

The attention given to the priesthood proved beneficial to France to a high degree. The ascendance of France in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries rested to a large degree on this Catholic reform spirituality. The new French clerics became ardent pastors and ministered zealously to the people in all their spiritual and human needs. Until the beginning of the twentieth century, the seminary of St. Sulpice in Paris was one of the most important schools of theology in France. It was also effective in England and America. Four French Sulpicians arrived in America in 1791 A.D. and opened the first seminary, St. Mary's, in Baltimore. The Sulpicians were among the first male religious orders which played an important role in laying the foundations of Catholic institutional life in the United States.

Edited from the following sources:

  • The New Dictionary of Theology, by editors Komonchak, Collins and Lane
  • A Concise History of the Catholic Church, by Thomas Bokenkotter
  • A History of the Church, by Franzen and Dolan
  • History of the Missionaries of the Company of Mary, by Bibeau and Courchesne

4th Sunday of the Year (A)

"Blest Are Those"

Human experience sees happiness in situations of joy, laughter, merriment and pleasant company. This is common in many cultures. But the call of today's is a call to discover true happiness in situations that initially are: poor in spirit, sorrowful, humbled, downhearted, hungry and thirsting for God, persecuted and insulted. To hope for true happiness in this gospel call is to believe in a faithful God-in-Jesus. This seed of hope implanted by prayer and works of mercy eventually blooms and re-blooms deep within every human soul perseveres in his faith in Christ. The happiness obtained in this context is more lasting and permanent - more than the happiness obtained from what is often superficial and temporary, and obtained through pleasures gained by external senses alone.



In the gospel, Jesus calls us to deeper happiness, the true and real happiness. This is a happiness rooted in following God's will: in humility, merciful acts, purity of intention, etc. All are called to live and seek this happiness, this "beatitude". Even when some sectors of society give more emphasis to fame, worldly success, money, and power, what is real often gets known and revealed. Temporal matters are not essentially evil, but if made more important than the values of the gospel, man can easily lose sight of God and the happiness he seeks for himself and others. If man were to use the temporal order without a Christian vision or an ecumenically universal hope, then it is no wonder why the evils that befall us cause despair, disillusionment, and destructive behavior. So Jesus offers the solution of the Beatitudes.



Perhaps the best source to learn more about this gospel and what the Beatitudes can give is found in the Catechism:

The Beatitudes respond to the natural desire for happiness. This desire is of divine origin: God has placed it in the human heart in order to draw man to the One who alone can fulfill it:

We all want to live happily; in the whole human race there is no one who does not assent to this proposition, even before it is fully articulated. (quote from St. Augustine of Hippo, De moribus eccl.)

How is it, then, that I seek you, Lord? Since in seeking you, my God, I seek a happy life, let me seek you so that my soul may live, for my body draws life from my soul and my soul draws life from you.(quote from St. Augustine of Hippo, Confessions)

God alone satisfies. (quote from St. Thomas Aquinas)